Is Drupal 8 really faster than its predecessor?
I have been told recently that the times when Drupal 8 was slow passed long ago, that increased number of abstractions in Drupal 8 doesn’t affect its performance, and that Drupal 7 hook system worse than Drupal 8 events in terms of speed. When I don’t believe, I measure and encourage others to do so.
Alright, let’s benchmark Drupal 8 and Drupal 7 one more time.
The environment
- Bare metal, Ubuntu, Nginx 1.10, PHP 7.1, MariaDB 10.1.
The methodology
- ApacheBench (ab) tool (what could be simpler)
- ab -n 1000 -c 100 for all experiments
- Each experiment should be taken five times (the average value goes into reports)
Examples of ab commands:
# Anonymous:
ab -n 1000 -c 100 http://drupal7/user
#Authenticated:
ab -n 1000 -c 100 -C auth_cookie_key=auth_cookie_value http://drupal7/user/1
I use Chrome Dev Tools -> Application -> Cookies to get the auth_cookie_key=auth_cookie_value pair.
The subjects
- Drupal 7.59 (installed from archive)
- Drupal 8.5.3 (installed through composer)
Configuration 1: Pure code performance
- Minimal profiles
- Disabled cache and asset aggregation
- Enabled Bartik theme for Drupal 8 (to match Drupal 7 default theme)
And here are the results...
rps - number of requests per second (the more, the better)
| Anonymous requests to the login page | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /user | /user/login |
| 809 rps | 1260 rps |
| 1,56 times faster | |
| Anonymous requests to a node page | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /node/1 | /node/1 |
| 665 rps | 1358 rps |
| 2 times faster | |
| Authenticated requests to a user page | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /user/1 | /user/1 |
| 658 rps | 259 rps |
| 2,54 times slower | |
| Authenticated requests to a node page | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /node/1 | /node/1 |
| 537 rps | 251 rps |
| 2,14 times slower | |
Configuration 2: “Real-life” conditions
- Standard profiles
- Enabled all built-in caches (expiration: 1 day)
- Enabled CSS/JS aggregation
- Generated 1000 Article nodes with tags and up to 10 comments per node (Devel Generate)
Thanks to @marcvangend for encouraging me to test this configuration.
Now let's look at the results...
| Anonymous requests to the login page | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /user | /user/login |
| 3525 rps | 1115 rps |
| 3,16 times slower | |
| Anonymous requests to the view page of a random node with tags and comments | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /node/2000 | /node/2303 |
| 3030 rps | 1110 rps |
| 2,73 times slower | |
| Anonymous requests to the frontpage (node list) | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| / | / |
| 3098 rps | 1073 rps |
| 2,89 times slower | |
| Authenticated requests to a user view page | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /user/1 | /user/1 |
| 468 rps | 123 rps |
| 3,80 times slower | |
| Authenticated requests to the view page of a random node with tags and comments | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| /node/2000 | /node/2303 |
| 279 rps | 78 rps |
| 3,58 times slower | |
| Authenticated requests to the frontpage (node list) | |
| Drupal 7 | Drupal 8 |
|---|---|
| / | / |
| 222 rps | 121 rps |
| 1,83 times slower | |
Conclusion
Although Drupal 8 has demonstrated a performance boost for anonymous requests on Minimal profile without cache, all other experiments have shown that Drupal 8 is still significantly slower than Drupal 7, unfortunately.
A couple of ideas on why you may not feel this difference:
- PHP 7 is much better in terms of performance. Many people started using it from Drupal 8 because at first Drupal 7 had some compatibility issues with PHP 7. Some Drupal 7 sites are still on PHP 5.
- Drupal 8’s frontend is better optimized, for example some render-blocking scripts moved to the bottom of the page, so it may feel like the page loads faster.
I understand that the results of my tests may not align with marketing strategies of Drupal service providers and other affiliated people, so I don’t expect you to share this post or thank me. But despite this, I know deep down you appreciate my efforts )
I hope you enjoyed the post and learned something new. To get my latest updates, follow me on Twitter @kkomelin